29 October 2013
US Says France, Spain Aided NSA Spying
Wall Street Journal
U.S. Says France, Spain Aided NSA Spying
Adam Entous and Siobhan Gorman
Oct. 29, 2013 12:55 p.m. ET
WASHINGTONWidespread electronic spying that ignited a political firestorm
in France and Spain recently was carried out by their own intelligence services
and not by the National Security Agency, U.S. officials say.
The phone records collected by the Europeansin war zones and other
areas outside their bordersthen were shared with the NSA, U.S. officials
said, as part of efforts to help protect American and allied troops and
The new disclosure upends the version of events as reported in Europe in
recent days, and puts a spotlight on the role of European intelligence services
that work closely with the NSA, suggesting a greater level of European
involvement in global surveillance.
The U.S. has so far been silent about the role of European partners in these
collection efforts so as to protect relationships. These efforts are separate,
however, from the U.S. spying programs that targeted dozens of foreign leaders,
including German Chancellor Angela Merkel, whose phones were tapped for years
by the NSA.
The NSA declined to comment, as did the Spanish foreign ministry and a spokesman
for the French Embassy in Washington. A spokesman for Spain's intelligence
service said: "Spanish law impedes us from talking about our procedures,
methods and relationships with other intelligence services."
In recent days, leading newspapers in France and Spain have cited documents
provided by the fugitive former NSA contractor Edward Snowden in reports
that alleged that the NSA was sweeping up massive quantities of phone records
in those countries.
Le Monde said the documents showed that more than 70 million French phone
records between early December 2012 and early January 2013 were collected
by the NSA, prompting Paris to lodge a protest with the U.S.
In Spain, the El Mundo newspaper reported that it had seen NSA documents
that showed the U.S. spy agency had intercepted 60.5 million phone calls
in Spain during the same time period.
After publication of the report in Le Monde last week, the U.S. Director
of National Intelligence James Clapper said that it contained "inaccurate
and misleading information regarding U.S. foreign intelligence activities."
He said the allegation that the NSA collected more than 70 million "recordings
of French citizens' telephone data" is false, but he provided no further
explanation of what the data in the documents showed.
Officials privately have said the disclosures in the European press put the
U.S. in a difficult bind.
The U.S. wants to correct the record about the extent of NSA spying but doing
so in this case would require it to expose its allies' intelligence operations,
the officials say, which could compromise cooperation in the future as well
as ongoing intelligence efforts.
U.S. officials said the Snowden-provided documents had been misinterpreted
and actually show phone records that were collected by French and Spanish
intelligence agencies, and then shared with the NSA, according to officials
briefed on those discussions.
U.S. intelligence officials studied the document published by Le Monde earlier
this month and have determined that it wasn't assembled by the NSA.
Rather, the document appears to be a slide that was assembled based on NSA
data received from French intelligence, a U.S. official said.
Based on an analysis of the document, the U.S. concluded that the phone records
the French had collected were actually from outside of France, and then were
shared with the U.S. The data don't show that the French spied on their own
people inside France.
U.S. intelligence officials haven't seen the documents cited by El Mundo
but the data appear to come from similar information the NSA obtained from
Spanish intelligence agencies documenting their collection efforts abroad,
The U.S. hasn't made public the role of European spy agencies in the collection
efforts because of the diplomatic sensitivities of outing partner services,
which the NSA relies on for a considerable amount of intelligence.
Public disclosure of European complicity in the collection efforts would
likely spark domestic outrage in those countries against their own governments,
and could threaten cooperation with the U.S.
U.S. officials said the European collection programs were part of long-standing
intelligence sharing arrangements between the U.S. and its closest allies.
Officials said the figures may not reflect the entirety of the phone records
collected by France and Spain.
New York Times
N.S.A. Head Says European Data Was Collected by Allies
By MICHAEL S. SCHMIDT
Published: October 29, 2013
WASHINGTON The head of the National Security Agency on Tuesday vigorously
challenged recent reports that the United States had been gathering the phone
records of millions of Europeans, saying that the records had in fact been
turned over by allied spy services.
This is not information we collected on European citizens, said
the agencys director, Gen. Keith B. Alexander. It represents
information that we and our NATO allies have collected in defense of our
countries and in support of military operations.
General Alexander said that phone data was generally collected outside Europe.
The Wall Street Journal reported on its website on Tuesday that intelligence
services in France and Spain had collected phone records of their citizens
and turned them over to the N.S.A. as part of an arrangement to mitigate
threats against American and allied troops and civilians.
But General Alexander and James R. Clapper Jr., director of national
intelligence, broadly defended the N.S.A.'s practice of spying on foreign
leaders. Such espionage, they said, was a basic pillar of American intelligence
operations that had gone on for decades.
Both men said the intelligence was invaluable because it provided American
leaders with an idea of how other countries planned to act toward the United
Such spying was essential, the officials said, because other countries, including
allies, spy on the United States. It is one of the first things I learned
in intelligence school in 1963, Mr. Clapper said. Its a
The two officials defended their operations before the House Intelligence
Committee at a time the N.S.A. has come under growing criticsm and calls
for a congressional review of the nations surveillance efforts. They
said members of the intelligence community were also American citizens who
were determined to protect American privacy while identifying national security
To be sure, on occasion we have made mistakes, Mr. Clapper said,
adding that the intelligence agencies would work with Congress to address
But the committee chairman, Rep. Mike Rogers, a Michigan Republican, said
he was disturbed by the criticisms of the intelligence services, adding that
many recent reports including the ones in Europe about N.S.A. collection
there were inaccurate.
This is the time for leadership, it is not a time to apologize,
Mr. Rogers said.
The intelligence committee hearing took place as key Congressional Republicans
and Democrats expressed misgivings in the wake of a report that the N.S.A.
had targeted Chancellor Angela Merkel of Germany for surveillance for several
Senator Dianne Feinstein, the chairwoman of the Senate Intelligence Committee
and one of the fiercest defenders of American surveillance operations, said
Monday that she did not believe the United States should be collecting
phone calls or emails of friendly presidents and prime ministers.
Ms. Feinstein said her committee would be conducting a major review
of the intelligence programs.
According to administration and Congressional officials, the White House
has told Ms. Feinstein that President Obama is poised to order the N.S.A.
to stop eavesdropping on the leaders of American allies. On Tuesday, another
supporter of the N.S.A., Speaker John A. Boehner, raised questions about
I dont think theres any question that there needs to be
review, there ought to be review, and it ought to be thorough, Mr.
Boehner said. Weve got obligations to the American people to
keep them safe. Weve got obligations to our allies around the world.
But having said that, weve got to find the right balance here,
he added. And clearly, theres were imbalanced as
we stand here.
Shortly before the hearing began, protesters holding pink signs chastised
Mr. Clapper and General Alexander, demanding they apologize to Ms. Merkel.
Its counterproductive to spy on our own allies, let alone our
own citizens, one of the protesters said. Mr. Rogers had one of the
protesters removed a few minutes later.