7 June 1998: Link to related
illustration of Menwith
1 June 1998
Source: The Sunday Times (UK) Internet Edition, May 31, 1998
Thanks to SH
The Sunday Times (UK) Internet
May 31 1998
Last week a German politician claimed a shadowy
US installation in Britain is spying on Europe's business secrets. Nicholas
Rufford investigates a base able to tap into any call, fax or e-mail,
and finds out who it really targets
SPY STATION F83
Josef Tarkowski, former head of counter-espionage
for the German government, is wary of using the telephone. An expert in
electronic spying, he knows that even when he is at home in Cologne his words
can be picked up by the world's most powerful eavesdropping station 400 miles
away on a windswept English moor.
"We know this technology is there and it is being used on us," he said. As
he spoke last week his words may well have been plucked out of the ether
by the billions of dollars-worth of listening equipment housed in Menwith
Hill, a secretive American base in Yorkshire. Built to monitor the Soviet
Union, it has continued to grow despite the end of the cold war, and
is suspected of being increasingly involved in commercial as well as military
New construction work is under way at Menwith Hill, near Harrogate, adding
three more giant "radomes". Each of these houses antennae which can intercept
satellite information and listen to the traffic of millions of telephone
conversations, faxes and e-mails from across Europe.
As the base grows, so does the unease of Britain's European partners who
do not have such a "special relationship" with America.
Last week Wölfgang Zeitlmann, chairman of the German parliament's commission
overseeing its intelligence services, went on the offensive. "It is known
that the Americans have spied [on us] in the past. We have caught them at
it. The issue is: were these just isolated cases or are they part of a wider
strategy by the American government," he demanded. "It is important that
both the British and the German governments pursue this matter with the Americans
as soon as possible."
Unease is also evident in France. "What is Great Britain, as a member of
the European Union, doing participating in a programme which since the end
of the cold war has concentrated on spying on her European partners on behalf
of the United States?" asked David Nataf, a French lawyer for a body representing
French defence, aerospace and telecommunications companies.
In Italy, Franco Frattini, head of the parliamentary committee for information
and security services, has demanded an explanation of Menwith Hill's activities
from Romano Prodi, the prime minister.
Menwith Hill is run by the United States National Security Agency (NSA).
It is the largest, most sophisticated and most secretive intelligence agency
in the world. Last week the agency denied that it spies on European countries
on behalf of American companies. However, almost right from the start, its
British base has had extraordinary capabilities.
LOOMING out of the mist on the North Yorkshire moors is a series of huge
domes, looking like giant golf balls, incongruous among the fields, drystone
walls and flocks of sheep. By night, the base casts a glow from the lights
of its 24-hour operation rooms and high-tech listening equipment. The perimeter
fence is punctuated by watchtowers and patrolled by guard dogs. Curious
passers-by who linger too long are soon intercepted by military guards who
speed across to inquire into the nature of their interest.
What goes on behind the razor wire is so secret that far less is known about
it than the workings of MI5 or MI6. British ministers in successive governments
have persistently dodged the subject when challenged about why the base continues
John Reid, the armed forces minister, refused to give any information when
asked recently why the base has taken on 200 extra staff. "I am not prepared
to comment in detail on the operations of RAF Menwith Hill," he said.
That name is itself misleading - it is not a British airbase. Opened in the
late 1950s on land purchased by the crown, it was taken over directly by
the NSA in 1966 and became its Field Station F83. It is now the NSA's largest
listening post in the world. Sprawling across 560 acres, it has an operation
centre and on-site town, including houses, shops, a chapel and a sports centre.
It also has its own uninterruptible electricity supply.
Early on it was given the task of intercepting what is known as international
leased carrier (ILC) traffic, essentially ordinary commercial communications.
In the 1980s it developed a new operations block codenamed Steeplebush to
expand its programme of satellite surveillance. A second phase, Steeplebush
II, was developed in the early 1990s. A third is believed to be in preparation.
Originally the number of radomes - the Kevlar protection covers which fit
over the satellite dishes or radio masts - on the site was just four. It
is now 25, not including the three under construction. The size of its staff
has kept pace. In 1980 there were 400. By 1996 the number had tripled and
has since risen to more than 1,400 American staff including engineers,
physicists, mathematicians, linguists and computer scientists, plus 370 staff
from the Ministry of Defence. In total the seemingly quiet Station F83 has
a staff as large as MI5, Britain's domestic security service.
They operate scores of systems for collecting data, including the main spy
satellite system for monitoring Europe and Asia, codenamed Vortex. At any
one time three Vortex satellites, positioned over the Equator, are in operation.
More recent, larger satellites codenamed Magnum and Orion are also run from
Menwith, and its sister station, F91, at Bad Aibling in Germany. What does
Menwith Hill listen to? Some light was shed in a report to the European
parliament earlier this year.
It declared: "Within Europe, all e-mail, telephone and fax communications
are routinely intercepted by the NSA, transferring all target information
to Fort Meade in Maryland [the headquarters of the NSA] via the crucial hub
of Menwith Hill in the North Yorkshire moors of the United Kingdom." The
report also details a system called "Echelon", a network of listening stations
around the world.
Each one intercepts millions of messages in speech or data commonly transmitted
by microwaves. Using computerised recognition programmes, the listening stations
attempt to pick out key words from phone, fax and e-mail traffic. When target
words are identified, the communication is recorded for further analysis.
Such information might arguably be needed in the fight against terrorism
or the drugs trade or other political purposes. But last month Alain Pompidou,
a European parliament technical specialist, said: "Echelon is in fact an
economic intelligence system - amplified thanks to the satellite network."
Critics argue that Menwith Hill can provide the NSA with valuable insights
into, for example, contract tenders, oil prospecting or international trade
Evidence that at least some of the traffic Station F83 listens to is non-military
communications emerged from a court case last year. Two protesters accused
by the Ministry of Defence of trespassing at the base were tried at York
Crown Court. In the trial British Telecom revealed it had installed high-capacity
optical fibre with capacity for 100,000 simultaneous calls - far more than
the number of lines at the base - implying that Menwith Hill was tapping
into the BT network. The base is less than four miles from another BT
installation, a microwave transmitter called Hunter's Stone tower, which
relays hundreds of thousands of calls.
Under a 50-year-old pact - the UKUSA agreement - the NSA is given a free
hand to operate from Britain, supposedly ensuring that the United States
shares its signals intelligence with Britain.
However, the NSA admits that although the facility is jointly operated with
a minority of British personnel, GCHQ is not automatically privy to the
intelligence gathered. Tapes containing data from American spy satellites
are returned to NSA headquarters; the sharing of intelligence is discretionary.
IF America has the means to spy on private and commercial calls, does it
have the motive? One reason is that companies may be supplying arms or components
for weapons of mass destruction to terrorists or Third World dictatorships.
But there have also been suspicions of commercial gain. In a row between
Volkswagen and General Motors over commercial espionage, it was suggested
that conversations by Volkswagen executives had been intercepted by the
The French have claimed that Thomson-CSF, a French electronics company, lost
a $1.4 billion (£858m) deal to supply Brazil with a radar system because
the Americans intercepted details of the negotiations and passed them to
Raytheon, the American firm which makes the Patriot missile; Raytheon
subsequently won the contract. Another claim is that Airbus Industrie lost
a contract worth £1 billion to Boeing and McDonnell Douglas because
information was intercepted by American spying.
But in all these cases there is no proof. That is the nature of the beast.
The eavesdroppers leave no trace.
Security is tight and few who have worked at Menwith Hill have ever talked.
One former US Air Force signals specialist who worked at a US signals
intelligence (Sigint) base in the 1960s has described how he watched print-outs
of commercial telexes: "I was provided with a list of about 100 words I had
to look out for. I had to keep a watch for commercial traffic, details of
commodities that big companies were selling, like iron and steel and gas."
An aerospace worker, who was at Menwith Hill in the late 1970s and early
1980s, also claims she witnessed the interception of civilian and commercial
By its own admission the NSA leads the world in eavesdropping technology.
And inside the US Department of Commerce is believed to be the "office of
intelligence liaison" - thought to be the conduit by which the NSA passes
on commercially sensitive information. Whether it is spying on foreign companies
remains unclear. The suspicion, however, may cause just as much trouble.
An American diplomat was expelled from Germany last year, accused of gathering
data on high-technology projects. Zeitlmann said the only answer to the
eavesdropping dilemma is for "the Germans to run the Bad Aibling base in
conjunction with the Americans and the British to do the same at Menwith
Even that might not solve the tensions. Nataf observed: "Echelon is an
Anglo-Saxon system. As de Tocqueville pointed out, the 'language tie is often
the strongest and most durable element which binds men together'. Europe
was intended to bind nations together with a common culture, political and
judicial system - but the English will always be a race apart".
Additional reporting: Peter Conradi, Michael Woodhead, Frankfurt; Kirsty
Lang, Paris; Matthew Campbell, Washington; and Ian Key
Cracking the Menwith codes
National Security Agency
World's largest intelligence gathering operation. Founded 1952,
headquarters at Fort Meade, Maryland. Commanded by Lt Gen Kenneth Minihan,
former air force officer and Pentagon official. Responsible for signals
intelligence (Sigint) about foreign communications, and information security
(Infosec) of US communications. Biggest listening post at Menwith Hill, Yorkshire
Codename for series of radio dishes at Menwith Hill intercepting
communications from foreign satellites
Array of dishes directing and communicating with US satellites,
including Vortex satellites operating over Europe and Asia. May have been
complemented or replaced by new system called Rutley
Main processing system for intercepted information at Menwith
Hill. Grouping of super computers, including Magistrand system believed to
be link into Echelon network
Global system of electronic eavesdropping, thought to be used
for commercial purposes as well as military spying. Monitors millions of
communications, uses computerised systems to target those of interest, by
origin, destination, language or key words. Targets tagged and forwarded
to Fort Meade for analysis and action
Advanced voice recognition and processing system in operation
at Menwith Hill. According to some reports, can be programmed with the voice
prints of specified individuals
Collection Transcription Analysis and Reporting division at Menwith,
employing language specialists. Split into two groups: C/TAR1 for Russia
and former Soviet Union, and C/TAR2, rest of the world
Protocol drawn up between UK, USA, Canada, New Zealand and Australia
identifying common security objectives and operations. Includes Echelon,
and assigns spheres of influence. NSA has ultimate control. Information shared
at discretion of US
General Communications Headquarters, largest British intelligence
and eavesdropping operation. Last week unveiled plans for expanded head quarters
in Cheltenham for its 4,000 staff. Operates the other main listening station
in Britain at RAF Morwenstow at cliffs on north Cornwall coast