2 November 2002
US Department of State
International Information Programs
Washington File
_________________________________
01 November 2002
(Column from The American Legion Magazine, November 2002 edition) (360) (begin byliner) (This byliner by Ernest F. Hollings, United States Senator (Democrat-South Carolina), first appeared in The American Legion Magazine for November 2002 and is in the pubic domain. No republication restrictions.) Locking Cockpit Doors Ernest F. Hollings America can prevent another airplane hijacking by following the lead of the Israeli airline El Al, which puts up impenetrable cockpit doors with one rule: once the door is secured, it is never opened in flight. Period. Should a threatening disturbance in the cabin occur, as happened on Sept. 11, no one can enter the cockpit. The plane will land as quickly as possible, and the troublemakers will be taken off to jail. No one has hijacked an El Al plane in 30 years. Last September, El Al's chief pilot told me, "Even if my wife is being assaulted in the cabin I do not open that door. I go straight to the ground, with law enforcement waiting." Securing the door solves many problems. No longer would you have to worry about planes flying into the White House, the Empire State Building or a nuclear power plant. No longer would you need to worry about military jets flying overhead, ready to shoot you down. And no longer would you need to worry about the debate of arming pilots with pistols or stun guns. As far as I'm concerned, you could put a machine gun in the cockpit - and the door would stay closed. Imagine if terrorists tried attacking a plane with an armed pilot. A flight attendant screams, "Open the door, he's strangling me!" The pilot, feeling responsible to help, might get off a shot but would instantly have a broken neck. And with the pilot's pistol the terrorists would have command of the aircraft and control of any passengers attempting to act like those on Flight 93 that crashed in Pennsylvania. Hunters know you lie still and get your heart rate down to fire accurately. Would that be the case during a turbulent flight, with terrorists busting through an open door? Absolutely not. Washington has it wrong if it thinks pilots should be armed. Our focus should be on protecting the security of airline passengers and people on the ground. President Bush could order tomorrow that cockpit doors be locked. (end byliner) (Distributed by the Office of International Information Programs, U.S. Department of State. Web site: http://usinfo.state.gov)
01 November 2002
(Column from The American Legion Magazine, November 2002 edition) (370) (begin byliner) (This byliner by Conrad Burns, United States Senator (Republican-Montana), first appeared in The American Legion Magazine for November 2002 and is in the pubic domain. No republication restrictions.) Arming Commercial Pilots Conrad Burns I've never met a door that couldn't be opened nor a pilot who's ever seen an air marshal. Our faith is put in "fortified doors," a seemingly nonexistent army of air marshals and, if all else fails, in-flight maneuvers to throw terrorists off guard. Instead, we should be thinking like the kamikaze terrorists these pilots could face. If people want to die hijacking planes, it makes sense to this old cowboy that it would help if they died before they get the job done. That's why I co-authored a bill to create a voluntary program to arm pilots and establish a training program for flight attendants. Deadly force is the only language of deterrence a terrorist understands. We are foolish to expect that security efforts will be 100-percent effective 100 percent of the time, just as we are foolish to believe in a perfectly impregnable door. A fortified door is not fortified when the door is opened, just as it is when attendants open them to bring pilots their meals. Rather than allow pilots to protect themselves, their aircraft and passengers with guns, should the government mandate that pilots abstain from eating? Once airborne, American flights are virtually defenseless. There are only 1,000 air marshals to service more than 30,000 flights a day in the United States. To build up a force sufficient to man every flight we'd need to create something nearly the size of the U.S. Marine Corps. This is no time to be gun-shy about terrorism. We give our soldiers guns and send them to Afghanistan, but we are prepared to let airline pilots fend for the plane and passengers with their bare hands. American soldiers aren't asked to fight terrorists with toys and temerity. Let's give trained men and women the right to self defense. And let's do that by using frangible ammunition, which disintegrates on impact with a metal surface but is strong enough to take down a terrorist. That's how the terror and the hijackings can end -- not with a whimper, but a bang. (Senator Burns is a Republican U.S. Senator from the state of Montana.) (end byliner) (Distributed by the Office of International Information Programs, U.S. Department of State. Web site: http://usinfo.state.gov)