Donate for the Cryptome archive of files from June 1996 to the present

5 May 2014

Snowden Redactions Tally

Related tally of releases: http://cryptome.org/2013/11/snowden-tally.htm

About 1,399 pages of the Snowden documents released are tallied here for number of pages unredacted, partially redacted and entirely redacted, the last suggested by released documents with omitted numbered pages and a few totally redacted by the outlets.

Snowden documents not yet released -- which some claim is a form of redaction -- range from about 51,000 to 1.69 million. The Guardian stated an original collection of 52,000 or more; DoD claimed 1.7 million taken by Snowden.

Outlets are arranged according to time of releases. *Indicates duplication.

Outlet Pages
Without
Redactions		 Pages
Partially
Redacted		 Pages
Entirely
Redacted		 Total
Pages
Published
Totals 1,038 290 305 1,399
The Guardian 213 29 162 242
Washington Post 171 58 140 229
Der Spiegel 66 32 0 98
O Globo Fantastico 23 4 0 ~87
New York Times 114 6 0 120
ProPublica 85 4 0 89
Le Monde 16 11 0 27
Dagbladet 13 2 0 15
NRC Handelsblad 1 4 3 8
Huffington Post 0 3 0 3
CBC 24 13 0 37
The Globe and Mail 10 8 0 18
SVT (Swedsh TV) 0 2 0 2
L'Espresso 3 - - 3
Trojkan (SVT) 27 2 0 29
 
Jacob Appelbaum 23 48 0 71
 
Information.dk 12 10 0 22
Anonymous/
New York Times		 14 4 0 18
NBC News 56 31 0 87
The Intercept 167 22 0 189
 

Outlet Title Pages
Without
Redactions		 Pages
Partially
Redacted		 Pages
Entirely
Redacted		 Total
Pages
Published
The Guardian
Totals 213 29 162 242
27 February 2014 GCHQ Optic Nerve 1 4 3 3
16 January 2014 SMS Text Messages Exploit 6 2 0 8
9 December 2013 Spying on Games 2 0 0 2
18 November 2013 DSD-3G 5 1 0 6
1 November 2013 PRISM, SSO
SSO1 Slide
SSO2 Slide		 7
1
1		 4
0
0		 0
0
0		 11*
1
1
4 October 2013 Types of IAT Tor 8 1 39 9
4 October 2013 Egotistical Giraffe 20 0 0 20*
4 October 2013 Tor Stinks 19 4 0 23
11 September 2013 NSA-Israel Spy 4 1 0 5
5 September 2013 BULLRUN 5 1 0 6*
5 September 2013 SIGINT Enabling 3 0 114 3*
5 September 2013 NSA classification guide 0 3 0 3
31 July 2013 XKeyscore 28 1 3 32
27 June 2013 DoJ Memo on NSA 15 1 0 16
27 June 2013 Stellar Wind 50 1 0 51
21 June 2013 FISA Certification 1 0 0 1
20 June 2013 Minimization Exhibit A 9 0 0 9
20 June 2013 Minimization Exhibit B 9 0 0 9
16 June 2013 GCHQ G-20 Spying 0 4 3 4
8 June 2013 Boundless Informant FAQ 3 0 0 3
8 June 2013 Boundless Informant Slides 3 1 0 4
7 June 2013 PPD-20 18 0 0 18
5 June 2013 Verizon 4 0 0 4
 
Washington Post
Totals 171 58 140 229
18 March 2014 NSA SCALAWAG 2 0 0 2
18 March 2014 NSA MYSTIC 0 2 0 2
2 January 2014 Quantum Computer 2 8 2 0 10
2 January 2014 Quantum Computer 3 0 0 3
23 December 2013 NSA/CSS Mission 2 0 0 2
11 December 2013 Excessive Collection 3 6 0 9
11 December 2013 SCISSORS 2 6 1 0 7
11 December 2013 SCISSORS 1 4 0 0 4
11 December 2013 Yahoo-Google Exploit 2 4 0 6
11 December 2013 Cable Spying Types 4 3 0 7
11 December 2013 WINDSTOP 1 0 0 1
11 December 2013 Co-Traveler 7 17 0 24
11 December 2013 GSM Tracking 2 0 0 2
11 December 2013 SIGINT Successes 1 3 0 4
11 December 2013 GHOSTMACHINE 2 2 0 4
5 December 2013 Target Location 1 0 0 1
4 December 2013 FASCIA 1 0 0 2
4 December 2013 CHALKFUN 0 1 0 1
26 November 2013 Microsoft a Target? 1 3 0 4
4 November 2013 WINDSTOP, SSO, Yahoo-Google 12 2 0 14
30 October 2013 MUSCULAR-INCENSOR Google and Yahoo 3 1 4
14 October 2013 SSO Overview 4 0 0 4
14 October 2013 SSO Slides 6 1 0 7
14 October 2013 SSO Content Slides 3 6 0 9
4 October 2013 Tor 49 0 0 49
4 October 2013 EgotisticalGiraffe - - - 20*
4 October 2013 GCHQ MULLENIZE 2 0 0 2
4 October 2013 Roger Dingledine (not Snowden) - - - 2
30 August 2013 Budget 16 1 140 17
10 July 2013 PRISM Slide 0 1 0 1
29 June 2013 PRISM 5 3 0 8
20 June 2013 Warrantless Surveillance 1 0 0 1*
7 June 2013 PPD-20 18 0 0 18*
6 June 2013 PRISM 1 0 0 1
   
Der Spiegel
Totals 66 32 0 98
29 March 2014 NSA Spy Chiefs of State 1 0 0 1
22 March 2014 NSA SHOTGIANT 2

NSA SHOTGIANT 1

 2

0

 0

1

 0

0

 2

1
31 December 2013 QFIRE 14 2 0 *16
30 December 2013 TAO Introduction 10 6 0 *16
30 Deceber 2013 QUANTUM Tasking (8 duplicates of QUANTUMTHEORY) 13 15 0 28*
30 December 2013 QUANTUMTHEORY 12 2 0 14
29 December 2013 TAO ANT COTTONMOUTH (images)
TAO ANT COTTONMOUTH (DE article)		 2 2 0 4
17 November 2013 ROYAL CONCIERGE (DE)

ROYAL CONCIERGE (EN)

 1 1 0 2
29 October 2013 NSA-CIA SCS - - - 3
27 October 2013 NSA-CIA SCS - - - 2
20 October 2013 Mexico President - - - 1
20 September 2013 Belgacom 3 0 0 3
16 September 2013 SWIFT 2 1 0 3
9 September 2013 Smartphones 3 2 0 5
1 September 2013 French Foreign Ministry - - - 0
31 August 2013 Al Jazeera - - - 0
O Globo Fantastico
Totals 23 4 0 ~87
7 October 2013 CSE Brazil Ministry 7 0 0 7
8 September 2013 Petrobas - - - ~60 ?
3 September 2013 Brazil and Mexico 16 4 0 20
New York Times
Totals 114 6 0 120
22 March 2014 NSA Huawei SHOTGIANT 1 1 0 2
12 March 2014 NSA Stellarwind Classification
NSA FISA FAA Classification
AG Dissemination
NSA Cryptanalyist FISA Database
NSA Spying Timeline		 37
18
2
1
1		 0
0
0
3
0		 0
0
0
0
0		 37
18
2
4
1
9 December 2013 Spying on Games 81 1 0 82*
23 November 2013 SIGINT Strategy 2012-2016 5 0 0 5:
3 November 2013 SIGINT Mission 2013

SIGINT Mission 2017

 10

9

 1

0

 0

0

 11

9
28 September 2013 Contact Chaining Social Networks - - - 1
28 September 2013 SYANPSE 1 0 0 1
5 September 2013 BULLRUN 2 2 0 4*
5 September 2013 SIGINT Enabling 2 1 0 3*
ProPublica
Totals 85 4 0 89
9 December 2013 Spying on Games 81 1 0 82*
5 September 2013 BULLRUN 2 2 0 4*
5 September 2103 SIGINT Enabling 2 1 0 3*
 
Le Monde
Totals 16 11 0 27
21 March 2014 CSE SNOWGLOBE 6 1 0 7
25 October 2013 NSA Hosts FR Spies 0 4 0 4
22 October 2013 Wanadoo-Alcatel 0 1 0 1
22 October 2013 Close Access Sigads 1 1 0 2
22 October 2013 Boundless Informant 2 0 0 2
22 October 2013 PRISM 7 4 0 11
 
Dagbladet
Totals 13 2 0 15
April 2014
December 2013		 Norway Assistance 0 2 0 2
19 November 2013 BOUNDLESSINFORMANT 13 0 0 13
  
NRC Handelsblad
Totals 1 4 3 8
12 March 2014 NSA Aids Dutch Anti-Piracy 0 0 0 3
8 February 2014 MIVD BoundlessInformant
Cryptome mirror		 1 0 0 1
30 November 2013 Dutch SIGINT 0 3 3 3
23 November 2013 SIGINT Cryptologic Platform 0 1 0 1
 
Huffington Post
Totals 0 3 0 3
27 November 2013 Muslim Porn Viewing 0 0 0 3
CBC
Totals 24 13 0 37
30 January 2014 CSEC IP Profiling 22 5 0 27
10 December 2013 NSA-CSEC Partnership 0 2 0 2
10 December 2013 G8-G20 Spying 1 3 0 4*
2 December 2013 G8-G20 Spying 1 3 0 4
29 November 2013 G8-G20 Spying - - - 1
The Globe and Mail
Totals 10 8 0 18
30 November 2013 CSEC Brazil Spying 10 8 0 18*
 
SVT (Swedsh TV) 2
Totals 0 2 0 2
5 December 2013 Sweden Spied Russia for NSA 0 2 0 2
 
L'Espresso
Totals - - - 3
6 December 2013 NSA Spies Italy - - - 3
Trojkan (SVT)
  27 2 0 29
11 December 2013 NSA Sweden FRA Relationship 0 1 0 1*
11 December 2013 NSA 5 Eyes Partners 1 0 0 1
11 December 2013 NSA Sweden FRA Agenda 8 0 0 8
11 December 2013 NSA Sweden FRA RU Baltic 1 0 0 1
11 December 2013 NSA GCHQ Sweden FRA COMINT 1 0 0 1
11 December 2013 NSA Sweden FRA  XKeyscore Plan 5 0 0 5
11 December 2013 NSA Sweden FRA XKeyscore Sources 1 0 0 1
11 December 2013 NSA Sweden FRA XKeyscore Tor et al 3 0 0 3
11 December 2013 NSA Sweden FRA XKeyscore Slide 1 0 0 1
11 December 2013 NSA Sweden FRA Quantum 1 1 0 0 1
11 December 2013 GCHQ Sweden FRA Quantum 0 1 0 1
11 December 2013 NSA Sweden FRA Quantum Accomplishments 2 0 0 2
9 December 2013 NSA and Sweden Pact 3 0 0 3*
 
Jacob Appelbaum
Totals 23 48 0 71
30 December 2013 NSA Catalog 2 48 0 *50
30 December 2013 NSA Catalog Video Clips 21 0 0 *21
 
Information.dk
Totals 12 10 0 22
14 January 2014 SSO (duplicate) 4 3 0 7*
14 January 2014 PRISM (duplicate) 7 4 0 11*
13 January 2014 5-Eyes Spy G8-G20 (duplicate) 1 3 0 4*
Anonymous/
New York Times
Totals 14 4 0 18
27 January 2014 NSA Smartphones Analysis 11 3 0 14
27 January 2014 GCHQ Mobile Theme 3 1 0 4
 
NBC News
Totals 56 31 0 87
25 February 2014 GCHQ Cyber Effects 0 11 0 11
7 February 2014 GCHQ Cyber Attack 10 5 0 15
5 February 2014 GCHQ Anonymous 8 6 0 14
27 January 2014 GCHQ Squeaky Dolphin 38 9 0 47
The Intercept
Totals 167 22 0 189
30 April 2014 GHOSTMACHINE-ECHOBASE
NSA Visit by GCHQ Lobban
PRISM with Olympics		 6
1
1		 8
3
0		 0
0
0		 14
4
1
4 April 2014 GCHQ Full Spectrum Cyber
NSA 5-Eyes SIGDEV Conference		 19
1		 0
1		 0
0		 19
2
20 March 2014 NSA Hunt Sysadmins 4 2 0 6
13 March 2014 NSA Third Party 1 0 0 1
12 March 2014 NSA Hammerchant

NSA UK on Mikey and Ibake

NSA Turbine and Turmoil

NSA Thousands of Implants

NSA More Than One Way

NSA GCHQ Quantumtheory

NSA Selector Types

NSA Quantum Insert

NSA Analysis of Converged Data

NSA Phishing and MTM Attacks

NSA Menwith Hill xKeyscore

NSA Industry Exploit

NSA 5 Eyes Hacking

 4

3

2

1

1

9

1

5

1

3

1

1

1

 0

0

0

0

0

2

0

0

0

0

1

0

0

 0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

 4

3

2

1

1

11

1

5

1

3

1

1

1
7 March 2014 NSA Ask Zelda 8 0 0 8
24 February 2014 GCHQ Disruption 4 0 0 4
24 February 2014 GCHQ Online Deception
(7 pages duplicates of GCHQ Psychology)		 49 1 0 *50
18 February 2014 GCHQ Psychology

37 Duplicates of NBC News

 41 3 0 *44
18 February 2014 NSA-GCHQ Discovery 0 1 0 1